In response to the Lower Moreland Township School District’s failure to take action to address anti-Asian texts among students, APABA-PA sent a letter to the Superintendent and school board members urging the school district to take all appropriate steps to foster an environment where all children can thrive and learn, including Asian Pacific American students.

Please Read and Share the full letter here!

February 16, 2021

Via email
Superintendent Scott Davidheiser, Ed.D. ([email protected])
Dr. Murray Cohen ([email protected])
Camille Murao Baker ([email protected])
Howard Patent ([email protected])
Alan Steinberg ([email protected])
Michael Berardi ([email protected])
Steven Geiger ([email protected])
Eric Kazatsky ([email protected])
Carole Natter ([email protected])
Lance Wolbransky ([email protected])

Lower Moreland Township School District
2551 Murray Avenue
Huntingdon Valley, PA 19006

Re: Texts Expressing Violence Against Asian Pacific Americans in Lower Moreland Township School District

Dear Superintendent Davidheiser and Lower Moreland Township School District Board members:

The Asian Pacific American Bar Association (APABA-PA) writes to express grave concern regarding incidents that involve texts expressing violence against Asian Pacific Americans being sent among a group of Lower Moreland Township high school students. Further, we find the response provided initially by the Lower Moreland Township School District (“School District”) to be inadequate and unacceptable. We were informed that these texts were sent in March 2020 in a group text among Lower Moreland Township high school students, which stated:

“My dad just gave me a f*cking facemask to take to states I actually hate asians”
“Facts like who eats a f*ckin bat”
“F*cking stupid asians shouldn’t be in this country”
“Every Asian kid i see tomorrow in the halls gets a spear”
“They should be stoned then lychee [sic]”
“This is why minorities blow change my mind”

These texts were reported to a hotline, and while the incidents were referred to local law  enforcement, the School District failed to inform parents, students, or the school community, nor did it  take any other steps. Not until last month, when the issue was forwarded to another group,  BlackPhillyStudents, did the issue come to light, and only then did the School District take further  action.

We understand that the School District is now in the process of utilizing a consultant to review  school curriculum and develop a plan, among other things. These are important steps and we urge the  School District to continue moving forward on proactively addressing and dismantling the environment  and systems that both permitted these texts to be sent, and that caused the failure by the School District  to act immediately to combat the prejudice and hatred underlying the texts.

However, it is unclear whether the consultant has any particular specialty in working on and  incorporating Asian Pacific American issues. Due to the specific anti-Asian nature of the texts, it is  critical that Asian Pacific American issues be incorporated and considered in developing and  implementing the path forward. Moreover, it is vital that the Asian Pacific American community be  involved and engaged in this process.

Unfortunately, these texts reflect larger systemic and historic racism against Asian Pacific  Americans and people of color that can only be addressed through proactive action with meaningful  input from the community. The racist and xenophobic texts stem not only from a long history of  discrimination against Asian Pacific Americans, but also reflect current anti-Asian sentiments across the  United States, where the transition from hate speech to violent acts can be all too swift.

In December 2009, growing racial tensions culminated in almost thirty (30) Asian immigrant  students from South Philadelphia High School being beaten up by fellow students, where several had to  be hospitalized. In the investigations afterwards, it became clear that the school’s failure to act  contributed to the escalation of violence against Asian Pacific American students. APABA-PA became  involved in denouncing the violence, advocating on behalf of the community, providing resources to  Asian Pacific American students and their families, and building bridges between the students,  community, school, and resources.

During the COVID-19 pandemic, Asian Pacific Americans have faced increased discrimination,  harassment, and violence.[1] Tragic examples include a 91-year-old Asian man who was attacked in  Oakland, California and an 84-year-old Asian man who died after being assaulted in San Francisco, both  in broad daylight.[2] In this region, an Asian Pacific American pregnant mother and her 12-year-old daughter were attacked in downtown Philadelphia in August 2020, with the assailant calling the mother  a “Chinese b*tch.”[3]

In recognition of the spike of bullying, harassment, and hate crimes against Asian Pacific  Americans, on January 26, 2021, President Biden issued a Memorandum Condemning and Combating  Racism, Xenophobia, and Intolerance Against Asian Americans and Pacific Islanders in the United  States. The Memorandum condemns such acts, and makes clear that governmental bodies should take  all appropriate steps to ensure that official actions do not exhibit or contribute to racism, xenophobia,  and intolerance against Asian Pacific Americans. [4]

Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972  require public schools to ensure that educational opportunities are provided on a non-discriminatory  basis. School districts can and must both protect students’ First Amendment rights and prevent  harassment, and ensure the right to freedom of expression and the right to be free from harassment are  compatible.

We urge the Lower Moreland Township School District to take all appropriate steps to  foster an environment where all children can thrive and learn, including Asian Pacific American  students.

APABA-PA, an affiliate of the National Asian Pacific American Bar Association, represents the  interests of the Asian Pacific American law students, lawyers, and judges and the Asian Pacific  American community across the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania by supporting the advancement of  Asian Pacific American attorneys and promoting justice, equity, and legal access, especially for all  Asian Pacific American communities.

APABA-PA is available as a resource to community members and to the School District. If you  have any questions or would like to discuss this further, please contact me at [email protected] or  412-251-9931. Thank you.

Sincerely,

Richard Ting

President, Asian Pacific American Bar Association of Pennsylvania

[1] See Madeleine Aggeler, The U.S. Is Seeing a Massive Spike in Anti-Asian Hate Crimes, Feb. 10,  2021, The Cut, The U.S. Is Seeing a Massive Spike in Anti-Asian Hate Crimes (thecut.com); Ron  Southwick, In Coronavirus Crisis, Asians in Pa. are Facing More Discrimination and Harassment,  March 28, 2020, Patriot-News, https://www.pennlive.com/news/2020/03/in-coronavirus-crisis asians-in-pa-are-facing-more-discrimination-and-harassment.html

[2] See Dion Lim, Shocking Video Shows 91-Year-Old Man Senselessly Pushed to Ground in Oakland’s  Chinatown, February 4, 2021, ABC7, Shocking video shows man senselessly pushed to ground in Oakland’s Chinatown, community on high alert – ABC7 San Francisco (abc7news.com); Dion Lim,  84-Year-Old Killed After Horrific Daytime Attack Caught On Video in San Francisco, February 1,  2021, ABC7, 84-year-old killed after horrific daytime attack caught on video in San Francisco, 2  suspects arrested – ABC7 San Francisco (abc7news.com).

[3] See Christie Ileto, Woman arrested following attack on Asian-American pregnant woman in  Philadelphia, August 13, 2020, 6ABC, https://6abc.com/asian-woman-attack-philly-attacked philadelphia/6369568/

[4] https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/presidential-actions/2021/01/26/memorandum-condemning-and-combating-racism-xenophobia-and-intolerance-against-asian-americans-and-pacific-islanders-in-the-united-states/